Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to browse my two papers on the topic: https://t.co/k7PnUBcrCU and https://t.co/LbDnUynAxT https://t.co/xeVr8yv7Xd
Edgar Dale's Pyramid of Learning in medical education: a literature review.
Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
Mentions per month
Jan 2019 – Jul 2024Where it's discussed
-
X / Twitter42 posts
-
YouTube2 videos
-
News2 articles
AI synopsis
What people are saying
The overall tone is dismissive, with posts labeling the pyramid as a myth and outright falsehoods, such as 'absolute rubbish' and questions about its origin, which demonstrate a focus on debunking rather than engagement. Words like 'myth', 'rubbish', and 'mythical' reflect strong skepticism, showing little interest or desire to accept the diagram's supposed influence, leading to very low impact in the ongoing discourse.
Most comments strongly criticize the pyramid, emphasizing it as myth or 'rubbish', indicating widespread disagreement with its validity.
Discussions show low curiosity, mainly dismissing the pyramid without exploring alternatives or deeper analysis.
Comments express dismissiveness and lack detailed discussion, with many posts curtailing the conversation with outright rejection.
The ongoing negation and calling out the myth suggest the post about the pyramid has minimal influence in shaping medical education practices currently.
Abstract in brief
- Edgar Dales Pyramid of Learning has been widely cited across various fields, including medical education, but the original sources and percentages it presents are often misleading or incorrect.
- A review of studies from 1946 to 2012 found that many researchers misinterpreted the Pyramid, cited questionable sources, or used circular references, leading to confusion about actual retention rates.
- Due to these issues, the widespread inappropriate citation of the Pyramid undermines the credibility of related research, and it is recommended that future work in medical education avoid referencing the Pyramid altogether.]
Top posts
Most liked on X and Bluesky(4/4) Ref: DOI: 10.1111/medu.13813 y DOI: 10.3109/0142159X.2013.800636
【悲報】(゜o゜;よくセミナーとかで紹介されてる「leaning pyramid」って根拠なかったんや。。。 Edgar Dale's Pyramid of Learning in medical education: A literature review 2013https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.3109/0142159X.2013.800636# https://t.co/XS8Qq8a3z6
@MaryJacobTEL1 @S_J_Lancaster See https://t.co/18SE2oDFJ6 by @itmeded
No, we DO NOT! Please stop repeating this myth. For more details, see: https://t.co/k7PnUBbTNm https://t.co/dzalp6rIyF
Edgar Dale's Pyramid of Learning in medical education: A literature review https://t.co/hDuwNJBRio #FLresearch @larbeam
All mentions
Debunking Edgar Dale's Learning Pyramid in Medical Education
This video explores the misconceptions surrounding Edgar Dale's Learning Pyramid. We will critically analyze its relevance in medical education and address the myths pervasive in learning methodologies. Join us as we…
Debunking Edgar Dale's Learning Pyramid in Medical Education
We will kill a myth in Medical Education, specifically Edgar Dale's Learning Pyramid. This video discusses relevant sources that challenge the validity of the pyramid and reviews its impact on medical education.
RT @itmeded: Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to…
RT @itmeded: Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to…
RT @itmeded: Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to…
RT @itmeded: Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to…
RT @itmeded: Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to…
RT @itmeded: Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to…
RT @itmeded: Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to…
RT @itmeded: Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to…
RT @itmeded: Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to…
RT @itmeded: Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to…
RT @itmeded: Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to…
RT @itmeded: Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to…
Please stop posting this abomination. If you'd like to see why it is absolute rubbish (apart from common sense), feel free to browse my two papers on the topic: https://t.co/k7PnUBcrCU and https://t.co/LbDnUynAxT https://t.co/xeVr8yv7Xd
رغم انتشار هذا الهرم الا انه لا توجد اي ادله علميه على صحته او صحة مصدره وخصوصا النسب المصاحبه لكل نشاط. للاستزاده: https://t.co/6OukPjUcY8 https://t.co/TsmUqaHm38
@Smellmeee @NathPribady At least it is the second criticism to the pyramid I found https://t.co/e5vbbBcUyi
RT @timbocop: @jhengstler PS check out @itmeded's paper on Dale's Cone: https://t.co/18SE2oEdyE
RT @timbocop: @jhengstler PS check out @itmeded's paper on Dale's Cone: https://t.co/18SE2oEdyE
@jhengstler PS check out @itmeded's paper on Dale's Cone: https://t.co/18SE2oEdyE
RT @timbocop: @MaryJacobTEL1 @S_J_Lancaster See https://t.co/18SE2oDFJ6 by @itmeded
RT @timbocop: @MaryJacobTEL1 @S_J_Lancaster See https://t.co/18SE2oDFJ6 by @itmeded
@MaryJacobTEL1 @S_J_Lancaster See https://t.co/18SE2oDFJ6 by @itmeded
You might like to read about the history and the bogus nature of the Pyramid (or Cone) and its percentages of learning retention here: https://t.co/k7PnUBtuEU and here: https://t.co/9G41mbbm4h https://t.co/p0ZHnGfX2a
(4/4) Ref: DOI: 10.1111/medu.13813 y DOI: 10.3109/0142159X.2013.800636
RT @santiagoraul: Edgar Dale's Pyramid of Learning in medical education: A literature review https://t.co/hDuwNJBRio #FLresearch @larbeam
RT @santiagoraul: Edgar Dale's Pyramid of Learning in medical education: A literature review https://t.co/hDuwNJBRio #FLresearch @larbeam
Edgar Dale's Pyramid of Learning in medical education: A literature review https://t.co/hDuwNJBRio #FLresearch @larbeam
RT @S_J_Lancaster: @dermott_paul Edgar Dale's Pyramid of Learning in medical education: A literature review https://t.co/TZKlgJ48iq
@dermott_paul Edgar Dale's Pyramid of Learning in medical education: A literature review https://t.co/TZKlgJ48iq
Here's a challenge: I'll offer you (or anyone) a U$5,000 reward if you can show Edgar Dale's 1969 text with this pyramid or these figures. See https://t.co/k7PnUBbTNm to read about why my money is safe. #education #meded https://t.co/6XW8Hnx4at
RT @itmeded: No, we DO NOT! Please stop repeating this myth. For more details, see: https://t.co/k7PnUBbTNm https://t.co/dzalp6rIyF
RT @itmeded: No, we DO NOT! Please stop repeating this myth. For more details, see: https://t.co/k7PnUBbTNm https://t.co/dzalp6rIyF
RT @itmeded: No, we DO NOT! Please stop repeating this myth. For more details, see: https://t.co/k7PnUBbTNm https://t.co/dzalp6rIyF
RT @itmeded: No, I'm afraid Edgar Dale did not do that. See more details at: https://t.co/k7PnUBbTNm https://t.co/OKwHuwXuGE
No, I'm afraid Edgar Dale did not do that. See more details at: https://t.co/k7PnUBbTNm https://t.co/OKwHuwXuGE
If you have based your training platform on this Edgar Dale myth, then I recommend you re-evalaute it seriously. See more details at: https://t.co/k7PnUBbTNm https://t.co/6dLiuQyA26
No, we DO NOT! Please stop repeating this myth. For more details, see: https://t.co/k7PnUBbTNm https://t.co/dzalp6rIyF
@larrykim Neat, but entirely mythical. For a start, how many teachers can remember 95% (60%? 30? 20%?) of everything they have ever taught? For details of this myth, see: https://t.co/k7PnUBbTNm
@SuperCamp Unfortunately, although these figures are neat, they are not true, and Edgar Dale never did say any of this. See more details at: https://t.co/k7PnUBbTNm #MedEd #education #teach
RT @ayako700: 【悲報】(゜o゜;よくセミナーとかで紹介されてる「leaning pyramid」って根拠なかったんや。。。 Edgar Dale's Pyramid of Learning in medical education: A literature re…
RT @ayako700: 【悲報】(゜o゜;よくセミナーとかで紹介されてる「leaning pyramid」って根拠なかったんや。。。 Edgar Dale's Pyramid of Learning in medical education: A literature re…
RT @ayako700: 【悲報】(゜o゜;よくセミナーとかで紹介されてる「leaning pyramid」って根拠なかったんや。。。 Edgar Dale's Pyramid of Learning in medical education: A literature re…
【悲報】(゜o゜;よくセミナーとかで紹介されてる「leaning pyramid」って根拠なかったんや。。。 Edgar Dale's Pyramid of Learning in medical education: A literature review 2013https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.3109/0142159X.2013.800636# https://t.co/XS8Qq8a3z6
KM
RE
A女
TF
RS
KN
JN
MM
إA
HS
TH
RM
SL
MJ
WH
SC
SM
Hل
IN
J
SL
JC
FC
RL
DT
CM
DM
MD
ふ退
ソ