Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
Many responses emphasize the importance of recent scientific studies, such as Dines et al. 2014, to correct misconceptions about whale pelvic bones, using technical language and references to imply the significance of internal reproductive adaptations shaped by sexual selection. The tone varies from supportive to dismissive, but the overall engagement indicates a meaningful impact on scientific understanding and public perception.
Most discussions support the scientific findings, emphasizing the role of sexual selection in shaping cetacean pelvic bones, with several dismissing older misconceptions about vestigial organs.
Interest is moderate; many users engage with the topic due to its surprising implications for evolution and anatomy, but some dismiss or dismissively critique the research.
Discussions go beyond simple support, referencing specific studies (like Dines et al. 2014) and full articles, showing a deep engagement with the science and its implications.
The discussions reflect a significant impact on understanding cetacean evolution, challenging misconceptions and supporting the idea that internal reproductive structures have functional importance driven by sexual selection.
@catvalente @ThomasMailund Super cool. The pelvic bones of whales evolve really rapidly, perhaps because of sexual selection due to this competition. See the work of @MatthewDeanLab https://t.co/5V8YSpjrvp
@DreamsTurnDark @cricketfacts08 @gunsnrosesgirl3 There is no such thing as vestigial organs. Those "vestigial" bones in the whale are necessary for its reproductive system; not leftover from legs. https://t.co/Dcm0xlhVOZ
@show_tao @GodaertStijn @FearTheSphere_ @1pckt @alanmrwilliams @Freewillburnin @RTW_Tweets @AwayFromTheKeys @Onychom @StandBackUp2 @ardenking55 @hackingx2 @deepinsights19 @YICYAC @IngridIngwah @A__Stout @NM_rocker @robster16a @PObdura @intelligent50 @juliuscaesarrex @points_tony @nilsatisnisi8 @Devil4President @rupejonner2 @Christgodtweet @Glad2bAtheist @lesgantssexuels @The_Real_BiM @zythophiliac @C_82l @PaulG16808960 @TheGod_Particle @MysteriousWay15 @alllibertynews @Baxter51557003 @GasmaNZ @PhoenixTruths @Nahdya777 @RoryLane @derbybbb @JK43108 @KaeAndersen @GrayHouse77 @tighe15 @yrysbryd @PleasureOfDoubt @Jandrewgotsguns @grumpy_dai @Grimasaur On whales, they play the vestigial card, though Dines et al 2014 reviewed plenty of science work indicating it was known they were reduced and acquired new functions by sexual selection https://t.co/lsZpA8K3wK
Here's Evolution Hour 178 https://t.co/9EpWiDPw8J hot off the presses
@mustafaaliuar4 @enis_doko @Mustafa_Sozen Hatalar var. Fosillerde gösterilen balinanın körelmiş ayağı değil. Bu kanıtlandı. Ayak olarak görülen şey yarrrak kemiği. Dines, J. P. et al. 2014. Sexual selection targets cetacean pelvic bones. Evolution. 68 (11): 3296-3306. https://t.co/AbDgnbaVGB
@Jesus_is_G_d @bubbacav85 @TertiusIII @TakeThatEpi @carlsmythe @tighe15 @StandBackUp2 @commonsensejan @michellmybell1 @rmbctious @ReviewResist @donholtmac @Cern_lXXl @Loriniowa @TedPerkins10 @LeannEAF @umfpt @Schmoop0521 @andyguy @MaryVMos1 @tklforgiven @geraldpayne25 @surgerysleeper @rorylane @rafearia @the_godparticle @RLBays @zythophiliac @feyeleanor @alan244g @phyzayo @funkydoolah @ScientiaPercept @2Cents69 @Mwforhr @omeagoz @Denbar64 @CollinOctantis @Kopernikus1966 @bobcat7000 @paulr140 @Pamiekp @TiSeven2 @CATGOD20 @delology @SteveTiger999 @amateurexegete Dines, James P., Erik Otárola-Castillo, Peter Ralph, Jesse Alas, Timothy Daley, Andrew D. Smith, & Matthew D. Dean. 2014. “Sexual Selection Targets Cetacean Pelvic Bones.” Evolution 68 (November): 3296-3306.
This video addresses pseudoscience in creationist apologetics, specifically debunking evolution claims, with insights from evolutionary biologist Jackson Wheat. It highlights the importance of scientific understanding…
This video discusses how sexual selection influences the size and shape of pelvic bones in cetaceans, highlighting that internal reproductive structures are subject to evolutionary pressures, explaining their…
@mustafaaliuar4 @enis_doko @Mustafa_Sozen Hatalar var. Fosillerde gösterilen balinanın körelmiş ayağı değil. Bu kanıtlandı. Ayak olarak görülen şey yarrrak kemiği. Dines, J. P. et al. 2014. Sexual selection targets cetacean pelvic bones. Evolution. 68 (11): 3296-3306. https://t.co/AbDgnbaVGB
@ldyny881452 @mohamed75636867 @sgdaoud2 @GodLessArea وغيره مثل ريتشارد دوكينز وجيري كوين عام والكثير من التطوريين قالوا أنها دليل على التطور ، وبعد أن امتلأت كتب التطور بهذه الخرافة جاءت الفضيحة في عام 2014.. نشرت مجلة Evolution التطورية بحثاً بعنوان : "الانتخاب الجنسي يستهدف عظام الحوض لدى الدلافين والحيتان https://t.co/GSyowTnNR5
@DreamsTurnDark @cricketfacts08 @gunsnrosesgirl3 There is no such thing as vestigial organs. Those "vestigial" bones in the whale are necessary for its reproductive system; not leftover from legs. https://t.co/Dcm0xlhVOZ
@TBabinaticos @Habdulah9 @origatoi @Noyoomi @lgnanet @mariozinholago https://t.co/t1M5x2JtN9
@Seraphim_derVer @TheDCProphet https://t.co/N7kltGJY4R https://t.co/oTpwZNkzHs https://t.co/v6KMtVLvE8
@JpakBioMed @dom_lucre @realDonaldTrump @BarackObama Not transitional! Dr. Lawrence Barnes has said, “Basilosaurus existed at a time when baleen-bearing mysticetes are known to have existed and echo-locating odontocetes are presumed to have existed.” https://t.co/V8lPme3cXl I can go through each of these if you need me to
[논문 해설] 짝을 안을 팔이 없는 고래는 수컷 생식기가 스스로 움직여 암컷 생식기로 찾아들어간다. 그런데 골반뼈가 수컷 생식기를 움직이는 근육을 지탱하는 중요한? 역할을 하기 때문에 더 이상 퇴화하지 않을 것이다. Sexual selection targets cetacean pelvic bones https://t.co/pMGy7B1cef
@John_lennox02 Okumanız bile yok müzedeki fosil de bile pelvis kemiğinden bahsediyor asjdashdfas adama resimleriyle kynak atıyoruz yine kabul etmiyor https://t.co/Qn69IHdbtM buda pelvis kemikleri hakkında başka makale https://t.co/vHXFwXrXmY Yalanlarınızı bilimsel makale ile çürütüyoruz işte.
https://t.co/sQxaJHLxYB
Rebutting Genesis Apologetics = Debunking John n Jane 5o12 https://t.co/IOIxigDcx3 via @YouTube
@Il7ed1 قرأت تغريدتك السابقة يبدو من الواضح انك ملحد مبتدئ ومع ذلك ننصحك بالاطلاع على الدراسات المتخصصة ومن ثم 'تحليلها' وهذا هو الاهم في حال اذا تمكنت من فهم الدراسات طبعاً، ثم ناقش بعقلك بدلاً من نقل ذات الكلام copy-paste من ملحدين اخرين https://t.co/wHolRPHXkm
Here's Evolution Hour 178 https://t.co/9EpWiDPw8J hot off the presses
Whale footprints were considered evidence of the atrophied organs of whales A number of studies shown that these bones actually have a significant benefit in whales. A 2014 study entitled “sexual selection targets cetacean pelvic bones” was published in Evolution Journal
@abuarka13806239 @1Rso2 @Ali_Albukhaiti هذه الدراسة التي تم ذكرها في مجلة smithsonian وكلمة تطور موجودة أكثر من 25 مرة ولم يتم التخلي عن تطور الحوت من ثدييات اليابسة https://t.co/fkUyv9QnzE
@Sapiens57 @HedaLexa92 @aisyashurfa @protomalay Ampun bang. Silap link. https://t.co/KZkPDsBGzd
@catvalente @ThomasMailund Super cool. The pelvic bones of whales evolve really rapidly, perhaps because of sexual selection due to this competition. See the work of @MatthewDeanLab https://t.co/5V8YSpjrvp
@show_tao @GodaertStijn @FearTheSphere_ @1pckt @alanmrwilliams @Freewillburnin @RTW_Tweets @AwayFromTheKeys @Onychom @StandBackUp2 @ardenking55 @hackingx2 @deepinsights19 @YICYAC @IngridIngwah @A__Stout @NM_rocker @robster16a @PObdura @intelligent50 @juliuscaesarrex @points_tony @nilsatisnisi8 @Devil4President @rupejonner2 @Christgodtweet @Glad2bAtheist @lesgantssexuels @The_Real_BiM @zythophiliac @C_82l @PaulG16808960 @TheGod_Particle @MysteriousWay15 @alllibertynews @Baxter51557003 @GasmaNZ @PhoenixTruths @Nahdya777 @RoryLane @derbybbb @JK43108 @KaeAndersen @GrayHouse77 @tighe15 @yrysbryd @PleasureOfDoubt @Jandrewgotsguns @grumpy_dai @Grimasaur On whales, they play the vestigial card, though Dines et al 2014 reviewed plenty of science work indicating it was known they were reduced and acquired new functions by sexual selection https://t.co/lsZpA8K3wK
@sethgambee @BrendanFitton @TheophilusPrime @TheWestonMike @HaircutSpock @TertiusIII @jools6691 @keitheyoung @zalphaprime @Melbajapan @TakeThatEpi @orna_verum @michellmybell1 @Mwforhr @andyguy @hauxton @rholftroy @EBatterson @JamesSandzik @stoneyweasel @C_82l @Jandrewgotsguns @geraldpayne25 @umfpt @DoesnAbout @TakeThatHomo @Cern_lXXl @Catholica93 @tklforgiven @RoryLane @AnchoredSail @rmbctious @Canna420Uk @c_element6 @1pckt @TBesserwisser @AtyHans @2Cents69 @AdamBlackstar @Jesus_is_G_d @LeannEAF @zythophiliac @gulminaHi @chrischristex16 @TakeThatChem @phyzayo @djslanty @carlsmythe @bubbacav85 Here's the technical paper for those who want to read the science without the antievo filter https://t.co/9iTOJ6GYGK
@Jesus_is_G_d @bubbacav85 @TertiusIII @TakeThatEpi @carlsmythe @tighe15 @StandBackUp2 @commonsensejan @michellmybell1 @rmbctious @ReviewResist @donholtmac @Cern_lXXl @Loriniowa @TedPerkins10 @LeannEAF @umfpt @Schmoop0521 @andyguy @MaryVMos1 @tklforgiven @geraldpayne25 @surgerysleeper @rorylane @rafearia @the_godparticle @RLBays @zythophiliac @feyeleanor @alan244g @phyzayo @funkydoolah @ScientiaPercept @2Cents69 @Mwforhr @omeagoz @Denbar64 @CollinOctantis @Kopernikus1966 @bobcat7000 @paulr140 @Pamiekp @TiSeven2 @CATGOD20 @delology @SteveTiger999 @amateurexegete Dines, James P., Erik Otárola-Castillo, Peter Ralph, Jesse Alas, Timothy Daley, Andrew D. Smith, & Matthew D. Dean. 2014. “Sexual Selection Targets Cetacean Pelvic Bones.” Evolution 68 (November): 3296-3306.
... 10.1111/pde.12516/full A link between human papilloma virus vaccination and primary ovarian insufficiency: current analysis https://www.ncbi ...
https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
Sci Rep 12, 12516 (2022). https://doi. org/10.1038/s41598-022 ... 10.1111/jzs. 12530 Here, we quantified the ontogenetic pattern for ...
... 10.1111/jcpp.13287 The effect of sleep deprivation and restriction ... 12516 Regulating the Suprachiasmatic Nucleus (SCN) Circadian ...
com/doi/full/10.1111/evo.12516. onlinelibrary.wiley.com. Sexual ... org/introduction-to-evolution/evidence- for-evolution/ https://slcc.pressbooks ...
... 10.1111/jcpp.13287 The effect of sleep deprivation and restriction ... 12516 Regulating the Suprachiasmatic Nucleus (SCN) Circadian ...
https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ...
I research and teach the evolution and epidemiology of infectious disease at Harvard's Chan School of Public Health. ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A ...
... 10.1111/gto.12516 The mid-Cretaceous Kem Kem beds of #Morocco contains an overabundance of giant theropod dinosaurs, including ...
... 10.1111/gto.12516 The mid-Cretaceous Kem Kem beds of #Morocco ... #Zoosystematics and Evolution. 100(4): 1473-1486. DOI: doi.org ...
... 10.1111/jsr.13708 https://www.doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00780 https ... 12516 Regulating the Suprachiasmatic Nucleus (SCN) Circadian ...
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ...
... 10.1111/jcpp.13287 The effect of sleep deprivation and restriction ... 12516 Regulating the Suprachiasmatic Nucleus (SCN) Circadian ...
What difference does it make in your child's evolution? And what kind ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
Both words, macro evolution and micro evolution, are ... com/doi/10.1111/evo.12516 (Further supporting reaearch: Thewissen, J.G.M., et al.
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ...
... 10.1111/jsr.13708 https://www.doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00780 https ... 12516 Regulating the Suprachiasmatic Nucleus (SCN) Circadian ...
... 10.1111/jsr.13708 https://www.doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00780 https ... 12516 Regulating the Suprachiasmatic Nucleus (SCN) Circadian ...
... 10.1111/jsr.13708 https://www.doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00780 https ... 12516 Regulating the Suprachiasmatic Nucleus (SCN) Circadian ...
Today I will expose an atheist who believes in Macro- evo myth without fully understanding the myth ... ... doi: 10.1111/j.1440-1738.1994 ...
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ...
https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
We could talk about evolution, diet, chemical waste, reproduction( we ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
... 10.1111/jcpp.13287 The effect of sleep deprivation and restriction ... 12516 Regulating the Suprachiasmatic Nucleus (SCN) Circadian ...
https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
... 10.1111/jcpp.13287 The effect of sleep deprivation and restriction ... 12516 Regulating the Suprachiasmatic Nucleus (SCN) Circadian ...
The workshop addressed early infection events, the impact of Mtb evolution ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/evo.12516. Here's an article describing why these bones exist... from an evolutionist source. onlinelibrary.wiley ...
Evolution of fishing capacity in a Mediterranean fishery in the ... DOI: 10.1111/fme.12516. Co‐viability of a Mediterranean demersal ...
... 10.1111/evo.12516 Obviamente, todos estos autores creen en la evolución, y que las ballenas evolucionaron de mamíferos terrestres, y que la ...
Collective Evolution et al = Outdoors & Freedom Party NZ. et al. Past ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
... 10.1111/evo.12516 · jqbr. • hace 4 a ... ¿Es verdad esta historia? r/evolution - Una ballena jorobada hembra encontrada con extremidades traseras.
... 10.1111/evo.12516 · jqbr. • 4 г. назад ... r/evolution. • -1 г. Эволюция всегда прогрессивна? 16 голосов за · 106 комментариев. Как Эволюция ...
... 這篇文章是來自「發現研究所」的嗎？ [已刪除]. 原Po • 4 年前. 文章在這裡https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/evo.12516 · jqbr. • 4 年前.
I always read that the pelvic bones found in whales are vestigial and a strong evidence of evolution. ... 10.1111/evo.12516 · jqbr. • 4y ago.
... Instituteのものだった？ [削除されました]. OP • 4 年前. 記事はこちら https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/evo.12516 · jqbr. • 4 年前.
https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
... https: //onlinelibrary.wiley. com/doi/full/10.1111/evo.12516. onlinelibrary.wiley.com. Sexual selection targets cetacean pelvic bones · 5 yrs.
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ...
Og der er selvfølgelig forsket i det. Reference: https://doi.org/10.1111/evo.12516. Line Toft Madsen and 4 others ·
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ...
... 10.1111/pde.12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... evolution of variants the vaccine doesn't cover (e.g., as predicted ...
--------------------------- https://onlinelibrary.wiley. com/doi/full/10.1111/evo.12516 3) "Importantly, OUR STUDY REJECTS A COMMON ...
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ...
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... Evolution: Non-sterilizing immunity allows the virus to replicate in ...
... evolution of more virulent strains of the virus. (c) Supporting these ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ...
... Evolution adlı jurnal "Sexual selection targets catacean ... 10.1111/evo.12516 (15) https://news.usc.edu/68144/whale-reproduction ...
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ...
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ...
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus vaccination and primary ovarian insufficiency: current analysis https://www ...
Melanin-based colour polymorphism responding to climate change http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/gcb. ... com/attachments/article/12516 ...
com/attachments/article/12516 ... Vulnerability of biodiversity hotspots to global change http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/geb.
Vulnerability of biodiversity hotspots to global change http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/geb. ... com/attachments/article/12516 ...
https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ...
https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... evolution of variants the vaccine doesn't cover (e.g., as predicted ...
http://www.collective-evolution. com/2015/01/25/mercks-former-doctor ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ...
... 10.1111/evo.12516/abstract. Join Facebook ·
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... https://www.collective-evolution. com/2016/04/12/lead-developer-of-hpv ...
... 10.1111/pde. 12516/full A link between human papilloma virus ... http://www.collective-evolution. com/2015/01/25/mercks-former-doctor ...
com/doi/10.1111/evo.12516/full. 記事から: "高度に縮小した状態であるため、クジラ目の骨盤骨は、陸生祖先の「役に立たない痕跡」と見なされることが ...
... 10.1111/evo.12516/full. Из статьи: "Из-за своего сильно редуцированного состояния тазовые кости китообразных иногда считаются «бесполезными ...
... 10.1111/evo.12516/full. Do artigo: "Devido ao seu estado altamente reduzido, os ossos pélvicos de cetáceos às vezes são considerados ...
com/doi/10.1111/evo.12516/full. 来自这篇文章：“由于它们高度退化，鲸类骨盆有时被认为是其陆地祖先的“无用残余”（Curtis 和Barnes 1989）。然而 ...
... 10.1111/evo.12516/full. From the article: "Due to their highly reduced state, cetacean pelvic bones are sometimes thought of as “useless ...
Global Ecology and Biogeography, 2016; DOI: 10.1111/geb.12516. Cite ... Ancient Long Snouted Croc from Egypt Rewrites Evolution. Toggle ...
http://onlinelibrary.wiley. com/doi/10.1111/evo.12516/abstract; jsessionid=DF4546AF7BD6BF84617C11521 9EFE6F0.f03t03 And it seems even your ...
Evolution 10.1111/evo.12516 (2014). Submit a Response to This Article. ×. Compose eLetter. Title:*. Title is required. Contents: Contributors.
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/evo.12516/abstract. There's the link to the paper. The OP is the journalist describing the paper ...
Daley, A. D. Smith, M. D. Dean. Sexual selection targets cetacean pelvic bones. Evolution, 2014; DOI: 10.1111/evo.12516. Cite This Page:.
GC
DD
RD
I
OL
L
J
M
HS
E
ا
NP
A