Placebo Effect in the Treatment of Depression and Anxiety.

CL

Charles Fain Lehman

@CharlesFLehman · X

https://t.co/1JQh21BHMU https://t.co/VHVazqe1Ne https://t.co/XrmUqdYB48

C

CEP

@CEP_UK · X

@Coucou_CFC @ReadReadj @Martin_Ploederl @HengartnerMP @joannamoncrieff @EikoFried @PGtzsche1 @Mad_In_America @BigPhilHickey "antidepressants are no better in treating anxiety disorders than they are in treating depression" See: https://t.co/XmaNCRBNEp & https://t.co/8Eey7JBGI5

NS

Nils Simonsen

@Nils_Sim · X

@JakeGoodmanMD I appreciate your effort and courage to destigmatize mental health.However, there are safer options than psychiatric drugs with comparable efficacy.Pls be mindful that you endorse the former over the latter with this post. https://t.co/y1bNGC5rE8 https://t.co/rRIGL7tO3J Take care

TH

Thomas Hesslow

@thomashesslow · X

@IdaHockerstrand @c_dahlstrom Det finns dock gott om studier som visar att allt möjligt har goda effekter vid depression och ångest. Merparten av effekten är placebo. Fördelen med dyra stenar är att de inte har så mycket kända bieffekter. https://t.co/XYxsV6jXgD

MS

Mark Horowitz @markhoro.bsky.social

@markhoro · X

When you look at two studies that have done this you can see in the group that has not been given ADs before so harder to unblind there is no difference in response between pbo and AD, https://t.co/5TiqSrGy8x (17/n)

SJ

Stuart W Bowen Jr

@stuartwbowenjr · X

@melina_manolas @benzosarebad https://t.co/Z5JC0Hu3sl

A

aaactcgcgcgcgcg ☀️

@wir_sching · X

@LurksOnX https://t.co/0s5nRIyCfw In dem Review ist die Studie von Cipriani et al. 2018 enthalten. Das ist ja der Sinn von solchen übergreifenden Analysen - dass man sich eben nicht jedes Paper einzeln anschauen muss, sondern dass der Wissensstand zu einer Fragestellung sinnvoll

CL

Charles Fain Lehman

@CharlesFLehman · X

https://t.co/1JQh21BHMU https://t.co/VHVazqe1Ne https://t.co/XrmUqdYB48

RS

Richard Bentall #FBPE @richardbentall.bsky.social

@RichardBentall · X

@DaveLeghorn @drjanaway https://t.co/TqNV2qM4yG

JC

JuanPa Chapela

@jpchapela · X

@MiguelBarbero7 @BeatrizTalegon Toma agua la tus barbas… https://t.co/NVT77LvKg9 https://t.co/EoPJHwrJ1I

SJ

Stuart W Bowen Jr

@stuartwbowenjr · X

@melina_manolas @benzosarebad https://t.co/Z5JC0Hu3sl

RS

Radoslaw Stupak

@RadoslawStupak · X

1/ How then shall we treat depression? One suggestion that has been made to me informally is to prescribe antidepressants as active placebos.. https://t.co/rJ8UXipSRe

WM

Wellness Matters

@bewellathome · X

@CaulfieldTim @jonathanstea @crackedscience @DocMCohen @DrvanTilburg @BlakeMMurdoch @StanKutcher @RyanMarino @DrShazmaMithani @CFPC_e @ABFamDocs Same can be said for pharmaceutical interventions. Regardless, no one ever died from a placebo effect. https://t.co/LTGq08x8qU

ŪP

Ⓐūštįñ Pörtęr

@Oldmanshouting · X

@nypost Placebo oftentimes is the only necessary factor https://t.co/XeHcqXv08N

YR

Yuzu Roromori

@YuzuRoromori1 · X

@Grantshotfirst People aren't happy? Nah, it's not capitalist ruling class to blame for outsourcing jobs, importing foreign workers, and conducting society-wide culture war against people, nope, it must be depression and anxiety, or maybe they are just schizo. https://t.co/vUJDRgcp05

DB

dharma bricoleuse

@ehipassiko444 · X

@sdcrosby @taalumot I'll do you one better and provide a link to a meta-analysis: https://t.co/Zq7oKowoJH

AT

Aussie Truth

@Aussie_Truth · X

@makemebethless @noplaceforsheep I believe dangers of some antidepressants outweigh benefits My daughter began self-harming after going on one so her Psychiatrists answer was up the dose I read more info about the drug & she shouldn't have even been given that med as she was under 25yrs https://t.co/uyBpflU4hZ.

JP

Jacob Petrin

@JacobPetrin · X

@mess0Falife https://t.co/Vo6mJXjpS9 “Antidepressant medications have little or no pharmacological effects on depression or anxiety, but they do elicit a substantial placebo effect”

KS

Klaus Schellhorn

@neuroconn · X

Placebo Effect in the Treatment of Depression and Anxiety https://t.co/yPNX2y86Nf

SN

Self Aware Narcissist

@hiimchiralkthx · X

Alsoooo placebo effect https://t.co/24JFspn2el https://t.co/lbL8WZd7Wm https://t.co/QStm1IoIlo

MS

Mark Horowitz @markhoro.bsky.social

@markhoro · X

@Medicalemesis @f_hieronymus @PloederlM @ueafam @johndrummond33 Kirsch's article seems to say the drug effect is almost gone with people who have used the drug before: https://t.co/vr1Mijkbik Anyway good night from me - thanks for the discussion

MS

Mark Horowitz @markhoro.bsky.social

@markhoro · X

When you look at two studies that have done this you can see in the group that has not been given ADs before so harder to unblind there is no difference in response between pbo and AD, https://t.co/5TiqSrGy8x (17/n)

SP

Steven Quartz PhD

@StevenQuartz · X

@guzmannutrition @hubermanlab although highly controversial, it appears most (if not all) of the effect is due to a placebo response. SSRI mechanism of action is still largely unknown - they have many non-selective effects - on GABA, glutamate, K+ channels. https://t.co/zBCFrJ70Sl

P

PsyDec

@Psy_Dec · X

@Sams_Antics @sbkaufman Kirsch’s work still holds up in regards to this https://t.co/wkscCdQZns

TB

Torpedo Burrito

@Ngatchou123 · X

https://t.co/F4FWntqpq6

MR

ME/CFS Research

@cfs_research · X

RT @cfs_research: @CyruxiME @MarekSJF @david_colquhoun There are a number of different aspects to the placebo effect. That Cochrane review…

MR

ME/CFS Research

@cfs_research · X

@CyruxiME @MarekSJF @david_colquhoun There are a number of different aspects to the placebo effect. That Cochrane review is from 2010, and there hadn't been any 3-arm RCTs comparing antidepressants and a non-placebo control group, but there has been one since then: https://t.co/X3WSjQqdoR

JB

Jo Beare

@JoBeare · X

https://t.co/6e5PDlpXbj

LC

Lauren C.

@Lau_Cob_ · X

@MissyKiku @Asher_Wolf @RACGP "However, analyses of the published and the unpublished clinical trial data are consistent in showing that most (if not all) of the benefits of antidepressants in the treatment of depression and anxiety are due to the placebo response" https://t.co/AB3JUI4pPs

E

Ethan

@NEthan_v · X

@AlaaBabidan @YaRrr89i @BandarAlsaqry ". Antidepressant medications have little or no pharmacological effects on depression or anxiety, but they do elicit a substantial placebo effect" https://t.co/REdIN72tPP.

T

tweetverax

@tweetverax · X

@Gh4nder @_jonasschnelli_ It’s true. In many cases people become chronic from drug access. https://t.co/UzjMjG1IvY

D

dbrodey

@dbrodey · X

Frontiers | Placebo Effect in the Treatment of Depression and Anxiety | Psychiatry—mind-blowing https://t.co/omDBvZiUXN

HB

HN Bot

@TechTweetBot · X

Placebo Effect in the Treatment of Depression and Anxiety https://t.co/IJmTezRNuV

TG

Tiago Garcia

@tiago_garcia · X

@giganteholandes @hackeusss Inclusive uma metananálise realizada pelo Dr Irving Kirsch por exemplo, demonstrou que não há muita diferença na eficácia com utilização de antidepressivos e placebos, sendo que na utilização da medicação, há diversos efeitos colaterais. https://t.co/lxHA0CrGev

DM

desastroeses_hoernchen #MHNursingIsPolitical

@desastroeses · X

https://t.co/ppKaiXK4is

LC

Lauren C.

@Lau_Cob_ · X

@ProfRobHoward @scibip Source: https://t.co/AB3JUI4pPs

SA

Spasticus Autisticus ☮️♿

@tpyamazaki · X

@thehealthb0t https://t.co/oke6IOggzQ

SA

Spasticus Autisticus ☮️♿

@tpyamazaki · X

@DrJessTaylor It seems that anti depressants despite massive hype for several decades don't really work. CBT was the next 'cure' https://t.co/oke6IOggzQ

TD

Tabarnak Dan ☣️

@TabarnakDan · X

RT @cleanslateblog: Improvement of an emotional condition upon taking a drug doesn’t prove that the drug “works” https://t.co/OLh3wJ4A7l

SS

Steven Slate

@cleanslateblog · X

Improvement of an emotional condition upon taking a drug doesn’t prove that the drug “works” https://t.co/OLh3wJ4A7l

G

Grace

@dignityhnrgrace · X

@winged @Andromeda10101 @JakeGoodmanMD People “don’t do well” on SSRIs because they are primarily placebo effect. Fact. Also, adverse reactions= body is signaling neurotoxicity. Please look beyond the pharma party line. https://t.co/TG0pmlTzDe https://t.co/AUFMYSApkS

NS

Nils Simonsen

@Nils_Sim · X

@JakeGoodmanMD I appreciate your effort and courage to destigmatize mental health.However, there are safer options than psychiatric drugs with comparable efficacy.Pls be mindful that you endorse the former over the latter with this post. https://t.co/y1bNGC5rE8 https://t.co/rRIGL7tO3J Take care

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@ProfRobHoward @PloederlM Why you claiming people said there no differences between drug and placebo @ProfRobHoward That's not what Kirsch said He said on re-analysis of the data, the difference was often *clinically insignificant* What is the scale? It's cut off your graph https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

TF

Travel Foreigners

@TraverseFore · X

@markrdavis @SameiHuda @Keith_Laws Ate you deliberately misinterpreting the science @markrdavis Or do you just not understand it? If mechanism of anti-depressants is placebo, not drug FX It is not truth teller reduced drug efficacy,but the doctors who described a drug for it's placebo fx https://t.co/8lLGHNVKT0

TF

Travel Foreigners

@TraverseFore · X

@SameiHuda @SameiHuda this is consistent with placebo/active placebo mechanism you claimed was misinterpretion of placebo data But your own tweet endorses primary mechanism placebo Please explicitly state your interpretation on placebo mechanism of anti-depressants https://t.co/8lLGHNVKT0

عا

عبدالله وليد المانع

@AbdWAlmanea · X

النسب في الدراسات مرعبة! https://t.co/H3Q28cLlVe

FB

Fiona French, freedom is bliss

@benzosarebad · X

RT @FalteringlyOn: @DickieRAnderson @DrDJWilde @jill_d35 @benzosarebad @peterkinderman @swinton57 @Dr_Ellie What did these RCTs show? Well,…

TF

Travel Foreigners

@TraverseFore · X

@DickieRAnderson @FalteringlyOn @DrDJWilde @TheCenterGroun1 Patients should not have to think to ask the question "what was the effect size of drug over placebo in RCTs" What patient knows to ask that? This evidence should be part of prescribing guidance to physicians Physician education is important https://t.co/8lLGHNVKT0

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@DickieRAnderson @DrDJWilde @jill_d35 @benzosarebad @peterkinderman @swinton57 @Dr_Ellie What did these RCTs show? Well, for the list of complaints clustered as "depression" or "anxiety" They showed that the drug was unable to achieve a clinically significant benefit over placebo. This means, statistically, there is a high likelihood that https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@benzosarebad @atomicaceso @EveSimmns @Dr_Ellie @DickieRAnderson @erumnomani @BarneyCalman @ProfRobHoward @AshCurryOcd @Rozewicz @SameiHuda @jonathanstea @Tiny__Biologist And Kirsch Why isn't he getting Top billing? Hellllo? Placebo FX? Possibility of active placebo FX? Placebo FX so high drug FX often nit clinically significant? How does that not get explained or factored into GP guidance?? https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@atpolgar @DuthieAlyne @T_A_Psupport @AnnaKin06551830 Why would you call them "sedatives"? Do you have any evidence of "sedative" action over placebo? Would not calling them by what evidence most strongly demonstrates Mean calling them substituting a drug for benefits most like caused in the main by placebo? https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@Wigglyworm8 Also, stop misinforming when the statistical evidence overwhelmingly demonstrates that the bulk of "benefit" in drug naive clients is placebo, with minimal drug effects, often failing to be "clinically significant", and these too may be "active placebo" https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@benzosarebad @_roseyesha @_roseyesha it's not true that a small proportion, or any proportion benefit from the *drug effects* substantially according to statistical evidence Burying this information is part of the game This is the mental health sector It's game is gaslighting https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@benzosarebad @SophiePorritt @Dr_Ellie @BarneyCalman @EveSimmns @DrRosena @KnightAyton @thismorning @Rylan @JonAshworth @jimmycarr @SadiqKhan @RealDeniseWelch Dr Ellie is spreading absolute falsehood, in saying that it is "worth the risk" to take a pill that the random controlled trials have made clear provides minimal, clinically insignificant benefit over placebo instead of open label placebo https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@ReadReadj @AlisonSmith29 @thismorning @AllisonSmith29 2/ Neither "side" is discussing the evidence of benefits in Random Controlled Trials. As Kirch's excellent research explains antidepressants have a very high placebo effect. Placebo inot "fake" a strong, potent effect putatively operant conditioning 2/ https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@ReadReadj @AlisonSmith29 @thismorning @AllisonSmith29 @ReadReadj Both the people advocating informed consent and those, unprincipled, professionals spreading misinformation are concerning me. 1. Informed consent is accurate explaination benefit/risk/harm profile based on evidence. 1/ https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@shvogt @HengartnerMP @johndrummond33 But without any data It's not possible to know & Knowing makes a huge difference Kirsch covers the placebo/active placebo effect really well Another study looked at the impact of biological vs contextual beliefs about "depression" https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@_eleven13_ @Alacoque6 @psychgeist52 @thismorning @rcpsych This is what bothers me about the open letter: why doesn't it emphasize the placebo vs drug DX in RCTs? As well as clarification on how much worse these are in children? Without this key piece of info The main message is lost https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@dranniehickox @Rozewicz @psychgeist52 @joannamoncrieff @thismorning @Dr_Ellie Mental health paradigm is shaming. The whole idea is to blame people for their crises & turmoil. Crises never arise out of nothing facts are woman misinformed blatantly on the evidence. If data say drug FX not clinically significant https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6 1/

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@shazamichelle @DuthieAlyne It's a *great* video @CEP_UK what I don't understand why start new people at all? How cost/benefit If no "clinically significant" benefit over placebo? Shouldn't GP guidance be stop to prescribing in drug naive clients When no clinically significant RCT? https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@Dr_Ellie Did not NICE agree to warn on withdrawal/dependence? Are you not bound to give proper information based on evidence, including many SSRIs don't have clinically significant "benefits" over placebo? NICE don't back "chemical imbalance", surely https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@Rozewicz @psychgeist52 @joannamoncrieff @thismorning @Dr_Ellie But they aren't effective over placebo, not clinically significant effectiveness for many So statistically it's likely people could have been "saved" by placebo, without the dangerous, sometimes lethal withdrawal Without harmful damage to molecular biology https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@Rozewicz @joannamoncrieff @thismorning @psychgeist52 @Dr_Ellie Yet SSRIs are not Evidence based & most do not achieve "clinically significant" benefit over placebo no meaningful drug benefit over placebo You do know that? Informed consent is law Why no crackown in person misinforming on TV? Shouldn't that be illegal? https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@FirstSteptweets @PatMcGorry @DrNicoleLee @NicoClark_ Pied piper and his band of flutes have so much influence,the scientists above sent on a wild goose chase after causal evidence of harms when alleged "benefits" Don't even have strong correlation in adults, none in children. Unapproved in children https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@TheCenterGroun1 @dranniehickox @_eleven13_ @DrDJWilde @RxSafety_org @JDaviesPhD @ReadReadj @markrdavis When there isn't even strong correlation on "benefit" For adults. There isn't even statistical correlation in manufacturer RCTs for children That is why the drugs are not approved Prescription is off label https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@SoundWellMusic @BecauseIMatter @psychetrick Becausesame lobbiests described inarticle & all other charities and practioners who spread narrative of benefits that aren't evidenced are very, very persuasive & influential. Despite correlation on benefits being statistical, not clinically significant https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

GR

GRATIELA ROSU

@GratielaRosu · X

Irving Kirsch did it again! :) Placebo Effect in the Treatment of Depression and Anxiety https://t.co/WPKLzyhkw7 I love this man!

PD

Phil Dixon

@DrPhilDixon · X

@sphams Indeed, and thank you for sharing, Steve, as many have said. I took Mirtazapine some years ago, but was recently shown this (peer-reviewed) article, which makes me wonder about SSRIs generally. Interested to hear the thoughts/opinions of others. https://t.co/zjorUQ65lD

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@regnans @notgoingquieter @DrNic16 When there isn't even strong correlation evidence on alleged "benefit" For adults For children they couldn't even get a statistical trial They are unapproved for children hence "off label" So you're a bit of Johnny come lately to real issues with respect https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@adamfare1996 There is not evidence of drug effects of SSRI of clinically significant benefit cause for concern Is it not? In adults In children, not even regulatory approval They could not even meet the arguably inappropriately low standards

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@gikkos1 including lack of sham controlled trials or analysis of nonspecific effects being the cause of alleged 'benefits' of ECT. Antidepressants also don't have strong drug effects and weak drug effects they do have may be due to active placebo. https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@johno0910 @RebeccadiGirola @SabraLane @leighsales media engagement led by self proclaimed "MH leaders" not engaged on placebo FX & withdrawal FX of SSRIs Akathesia gets no attention in Aus. correlation on youth suicide ignored for no "causal link" despite poor/dubious correlative data in "benefits" https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DB

DANIEL BRUMMITT

@dan__brummitt · X

RT @FalteringlyOn: @dan__brummitt Did you see these? Very similar. In agreement. Written by Doctors. The first one was result of probe laun…

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@dan__brummitt Did you see these? Very similar. In agreement. Written by Doctors. The first one was result of probe launched by Australian Health minister Openly discusses misinformation spread by 2 prominent Psychiatrists https://t.co/8a1Lo7nFi1 https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6 https://t.co/WBIchXfihO

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@dan__brummitt @_d_a_n_i_e_l__b @thebeatles https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@engagedpractx @SimonKatterl @psychepi plus there's Kirsch's work on FDA trial reanalysis in adules i wish someone would take a look at evidence review in context of this - &put easy read explainer for ppl w/ cognitive disability. how does this compare to 2009 evidence review methodologies? https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@Samoskal What concerns me, is that Kirsch's reanalysis of FDA data that was obtained later shows that SSRI is mostly placebo Even in adults So what's going on with youth? How well do even evidence of moderate benefits hold up in light of this info? https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

DC

Doing the best I can

@FalteringlyOn · X

@ShoreyThe3rd @PatMcGorry @KitanaValentine @suicideresearch @jeff_kennett @60Mins @DRC_AU It's actually wild, prominent Australian psychiatrists tried to discredit FDA blackbox warning on SSRIs &TGA didn't echo the warning. Claims it was cost/benefit ratio in favour of SSRIs makes no sense in light of minimal/negligible clinical FX over placebo https://t.co/4ZyruuMPk6

S

| sav |

@wr0ngf1t · X

Also this article by Dr. Irving Kirsch a professor at Harvard Medical School is really good talking about double blinds broken in clinical trials for SSRIs & the placebo effect. https://t.co/e1uIZLLtUJ

LC

Lauren C.

@Lau_Cob_ · X

@eactnowuk @davecurtis314 @ProfLAppleby @ProfRobHoward The serotonin hypothesis of depression is far from proven. It’s most likely a spurious correlation related to a survival adaption to mast cell overactivation. The dopamine hypothesis has a lot more supporting evidence. https://t.co/AB3JUHMgBk

LC

Lauren C.

@Lau_Cob_ · X

@SameiHuda @DrEvgenyLegedin @PureDemocracyNZ @askdheeraj @joannamoncrieff While I think there is strong evidence pointing towards mast cell activation and dopamine having multi dimensional role in depressive pathogenesis, I am skeptical re: the serotonin hypothesis - upon which the whole antidepressant industry is based off. https://t.co/AB3JUHMgBk

LC

Lauren C.

@Lau_Cob_ · X

https://t.co/AB3JUHMgBk https://t.co/FlHPOnSpTY

BW

Bruce Waynejrv

@Bob_Stinson1234 · X

https://t.co/fgBU2AjMxd

Z

ZKA

@0knowledgeactor · X

Now combine that with the concern that SSRIs are no more effective than placebo (https://t.co/YQoFomGgEA) https://t.co/4ihEfD7QcK

LS

Lee Stevenson

@bashuser · X

Placebo Effect in the Treatment of Depression and Anxiety https://t.co/2qdXQtpF9Z

JB

Johannes Bohacek

@BohacekLab · X

Embarrassing question to researchers/clinicians: what's with this hypothesis that most (if not all) of the benefits of antidepressants (for depression and anxiety) are due to the placebo response? Is this a fringe view? I want to cover placebo in lecture.. https://t.co/8YLBTv2sQV

DP

Don't believe the propaganda

@Dontbel90127593 · X

RT @joannamoncrieff: In this paper, Irving Kirsch reports results of FDA's own meta-analysis of antidepressant studies which finds miniscul…

RG

Richard Gipps

@DrGipps · X

@awaisaftab @David27221696 That sounds right -although 'actual’ ADs don’t always significantly outperform placebo either. I’d be interested to see the trial papers you’ve in mind. I just read Kirsch 2019 which was interesting. https://t.co/VYPn5sA5OZ

PU

Peter Malliaros Co-Founder UrVOTE

@EqualOpp4All · X

@JodiMcKayMP @chiccomarx As long as that doesn’t automatically mean that they’re prescribed with anti-depressants, as they’ve been found to be less effective than a sugar pill, but with tragic side effects. “Placebo Effect in the Treatment of Depression and Anxiety” https://t.co/w64YuLZg44

L

~Leaves~

@Through_Leaves · X

@Herne_TheHunter @psychunseen @DrSathyaPrakas1 @AllenFrancesMD @awaisaftab @askdheeraj @EsquireRN @evolutionarypsy @J_F_Hayes @dawso007 @DrJefferyHayden @MaryFernando_ @jonathanstea @tylerblack32 @amybarnhorst @sameerjauhar @SameiHuda @ProfRobHoward @DrHowardLiu @DrvanTilburg @wendyburn @CoyneoftheRealm @cadoganhealthc1 It is not “my” argument – it is what research clearly shows. Also see the following (much newer) article that specifically discusses the placebo effect in psychiatry: https://t.co/Yotwg9lJtB

PU

Peter Malliaros Co-Founder UrVOTE

@EqualOpp4All · X

@elyasgarad Hi all, during these stressful times it’s important to seek help when needed however, please read the following research papers before taking Any Anti-Depresant pharmachalogical agents. You’re life may well depend on it! https://t.co/w64YuLZg44; https://t.co/wIT8zZ9rUe

TH

Thomas Hesslow

@thomashesslow · X

@IdaHockerstrand @c_dahlstrom Det finns dock gott om studier som visar att allt möjligt har goda effekter vid depression och ångest. Merparten av effekten är placebo. Fördelen med dyra stenar är att de inte har så mycket kända bieffekter. https://t.co/XYxsV6jXgD

S

sic

@kimvie · X

RT @joannamoncrieff: In this paper, Irving Kirsch reports results of FDA's own meta-analysis of antidepressant studies which finds miniscul…

KD

Kindly #deprescribe -- taper psychiatric drugs

@Altostrata · X

RT @CEP_UK: @Coucou_CFC @ReadReadj @Martin_Ploederl @HengartnerMP @joannamoncrieff @EikoFried @PGtzsche1 @Mad_In_America @BigPhilHickey "an…

D

Dee

@Deedoherty2 · X

RT @CEP_UK: @Coucou_CFC @ReadReadj @Martin_Ploederl @HengartnerMP @joannamoncrieff @EikoFried @PGtzsche1 @Mad_In_America @BigPhilHickey "an…

C

CEP

@CEP_UK · X

@Coucou_CFC @ReadReadj @Martin_Ploederl @HengartnerMP @joannamoncrieff @EikoFried @PGtzsche1 @Mad_In_America @BigPhilHickey "antidepressants are no better in treating anxiety disorders than they are in treating depression" See: https://t.co/XmaNCRBNEp & https://t.co/8Eey7JBGI5

SC

Sarah P. Hancock, MS, CRC ♿

@PsychRecovery · X

RT @joannamoncrieff: In this paper, Irving Kirsch reports results of FDA's own meta-analysis of antidepressant studies which finds miniscul…

B

BS

@SinnerBenjamin · X

RT @joannamoncrieff: In this paper, Irving Kirsch reports results of FDA's own meta-analysis of antidepressant studies which finds miniscul…

J

Jonathan

@Polyphloisbic · X

RT @joannamoncrieff: In this paper, Irving Kirsch reports results of FDA's own meta-analysis of antidepressant studies which finds miniscul…

SC

Sociedad Española de Psicología Clínica

@SEPC_ANPIR · X

RT @joannamoncrieff: In this paper, Irving Kirsch reports results of FDA's own meta-analysis of antidepressant studies which finds miniscul…

NS

Nils Simonsen

@Nils_Sim · X

RT @joannamoncrieff: In this paper, Irving Kirsch reports results of FDA's own meta-analysis of antidepressant studies which finds miniscul…

CL

Carlos J Losada

@calrosl · X

RT @joannamoncrieff: In this paper, Irving Kirsch reports results of FDA's own meta-analysis of antidepressant studies which finds miniscul…

O

Orson

@Orsonkartt · X

RT @joannamoncrieff: In this paper, Irving Kirsch reports results of FDA's own meta-analysis of antidepressant studies which finds miniscul…

HV

Harriet Vogt

@shvogt · X

RT @joannamoncrieff: In this paper, Irving Kirsch reports results of FDA's own meta-analysis of antidepressant studies which finds miniscul…

DS

Dr. Tanju Sürmeli

@drtanjusurmeli · X

RT @joannamoncrieff: In this paper, Irving Kirsch reports results of FDA's own meta-analysis of antidepressant studies which finds miniscul…

PJ

Peter Jones

@PeterJones2021 · X

RT @joannamoncrieff: In this paper, Irving Kirsch reports results of FDA's own meta-analysis of antidepressant studies which finds miniscul…

LW

Laurence Astill Wright

@laurence_aw · X

https://t.co/RsjZDymkXC

N

NeoTP

@NeoTP · X

A veces conviene recordar que los efectos clínicos positivos de los antidepresivos y el placebo no se diferencian apenas. Mientras que los efectos secundarios... pues sí. https://t.co/RCYT9bZaOZ